• Home
  • Domains
  • Internet & Tech
  • Security & Privacy
  • Google & Search
  • Editorial Praise
  • Contact

Strategic Revenue - Domain and Internet News

Internet news authored by John Colascione

Register Domain Names

  • Isn’t Print Dead?
  • Killer Acquisition
  • New gTLD Death
  • Online Censorship
  • Semantic Indexing
  • You’re A Loser
You are here: Home / Domain Names / Panels Consistently Find That “Domain Investing” Is Legitimate Bona Fide Offering

Panels Consistently Find That “Domain Investing” Is Legitimate Bona Fide Offering

October 10, 2019 By John Colascione 2 Comments

*** Here Is A List Of Some Of The Best Domain Name Resources Available ***

Register Domain Names

PALM BEACH, FL – Upon reading recent news from “Neus News”, I stumbled onto an interesting find where Howard Neu, a long-time attorney for the domain name industry, was representing a domain owner in a case where Oath Inc. (now Verizon Media), the company that purchased Yahoo! related assets in 2017 for $4.83 billion, claimed the domain name “YMobile.com” was infringing on Yahoo! related trademarks such as “Y”’ and “Y!”, as well as “Y Mobile” (although Y Mobile is only held in Japan). The case was heard just recently on October 8th, 2019. (Oath Inc. v. Mira Hold / Mira Holdings, Inc)

According to Neu, regarding the complaint, a decision was made by the WIPO panel to dismiss or deny the complaint according to the panel’s belief that “Domain Investing” by itself does not constitute bad faith.

Generic domain name reselling is considered to be a legitimate business so long as it does not appear that the Respondent attempts to target the Complainant’s mark.”

That decision referenced another to support its findings (Platterz Inc. v. Andrew Melcher, WIPO Claim Number FA1705001729887) which prompted me to take a look at it, and to examine some others to read the referenced cases which are all provided below. Most are WIPO decisions but a few are from the National Arbitration Forum.

Complainant argues that domain investing, which is what it accuses Respondent of doing, is contrary to the Policy, but UDRP panels have consistently found that investing in genuinely generic terms, for purpose of resale, is a legitimate business and that the acquisition of domain names consisting of common, dictionary terms for resale can confer rights and legitimate interests upon entrepreneurs who engage in this activity.

Platterz Inc. v. Andrew Melcher Claim Number: FA1705001729887 National Arbitration Forum (June 19, 2017)

Due to the commercial value of descriptive or generic domain names it has become a business model to register and sell such domain names to the highest potential bidder. Such a practice – including the sale of the domain name – has been found to constitute use of the domain name concerned in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services provided that the registration of the domain name was not undertaken with intent to profit from or otherwise abuse a complainant’s trademark rights.

X6D Limited v. Telepathy, Inc. WIPO Case No. D2010-1519 (Nov. 16, 2010)

Respondent has registered over 400 domain names, all of which contain or are composed of common words or short phrases from the English language or misspellings of such words. In trademark terms, many of these domain names would be considered descriptive of certain goods or services, or generic. Registration of descriptive or generic terms as a domain name is possible under the .com TLD. As the commercial value of such domain names has increased, brokers like Respondent have seized the opportunity to sell such domain names to the highest bidder. In principle, such a practice may constitute use of the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services (i.e. the sale of the domain name itself).

Allocation Network GmbH v. Steve Gregory, WIPO Case No. D2000-0016 (Mar. 24, 2000)

Since registering generic names, even with the intent to resell them, is a legitimate business activity, a majority of the Panel holds that the Respondents have a legitimate interest in the contested domain name.

John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd v. Domain Names 4U and Fred Gray Case No. D2000-1403 (Dec. 13, 2000)

As the commercial value of descriptive or generic domain names has increased, many people have seized the opportunity to register and sell such domain names to the highest bidder in principle, such a practice (i.e. the sale of the domain name itself) may constitute use of the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services.

General Machine Products Company, Inc. v. Prime Domains (a/k/a Telepathy, Inc.) National Arbitration Forum File FA0001000092531

Respondent is in the business of creating and supplying names for new entities, including acquiring expired domain names. This is a legitimate activity in which there are numerous suppliers in the United States.

Alphalogix Inc. v. DNS Servs., FA 491557 (National Arbitration Forum, July 26, 2005).

Respondent is in the business of selling domain names consisting of generic or descriptive terms. The Panel finds that selling domain names consisting of generic or descriptive terms is a bona fide offering of goods or services pursuant to Policy.

InCorp Services, Inc. v RareNames, WebReg, Claim Number: FA0509000559911 – (National Arbitration Forum, Nov. 10, 2005)

It is interesting to read over case after case, and there are likely many more examples to be dug up, where domain name investing is deemed a clear and legitimate offering of bona fide goods and services.

John Colascione
John Colascione

About The Author: John Colascione is Chief Executive Officer of Internet Marketing Services Inc. He specializes in Website Monetization, is a Google AdWords Certified Professional, authored a ‘how to’ book called ”Mastering Your Website‘, and is a key player in several Internet related businesses through his search engine strategy brand Searchen Networks®

Filed Under: Domain Names Tagged With: Andrew Melcher, Attorney, Attorneys, Bad Faith, Bona Fide, Common Phrases, Complainant, Complaints, Decision, Decisions, Descriptive, Domain Attorney, Domain Investing, Domain Name, Domain Name Broker, Domain Name Disputes, Domain Name Forum, Domain Name Investment, Domain Name Investor, Domain Name Investors, Domain Name Owner, Domain Name Owners, Domain Name Reseller, Domain Name Resolution, Domain Name Rights, Domain Names, Domain Names 4U, Domains, Domains Reseller, English, Entrepreneurs, Fairfax Publications, Fred Gray, General Machine Products, Generic, Generic Domain, Generic Domain Name, Generic Domain Names, Generic Domains, InCorp Services, Keyphrases, Keyword Phrases, Legitimate, Legitimate Interest, Mira Hold, Mira Holdings, National Arbitration Forum, Neus News, Oath, Oath Inc., Panel, Phrases, Platterz Inc., Prime Domains, RareNames, Resell, Reseller, Resellers, Respondent, Selling, Telepathy, Trademark, Trademark Infringement, Trademarks, UDRP Panelists, Verizon Media, WIPO, X6D Limited, YMobile.com

*** Here Is A List Of Some Of The Best Domain Name Resources Available ***

Register Domain Names

Comments

  1. Rick Schwartz says

    October 10, 2019 at 5:33 am

    Good job collecting this info!!

    Reply
    • John Colascione says

      October 10, 2019 at 7:17 am

      Thank you Rick.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search This Site

by: John Colascione

John Colascione

Logo
John Colascione is Chief Executive of Internet Marketing Services Inc. He specializes in Website Monetization, authored a book called Mastering Your Website, and is a key player in several Internet businesses through his brand SEARCHEN®

The Published Reporter

The Published Reporter

Fellow Me

Twitter

In The News

  • DNJournal: New Book From Veteran Domainer
  • From Brandable to Exact-Match Geo Domain
  • InnovateLI: Two Deals, One Very Interesting Digital
  • Internet Commerce Association: John Colascione
  • NamesCon: Featured Attendee: John Colascione
  • Long Island Media Inc, SmartCEO, Future 50
  • Speakers, Name Summit, John Colascione
  • Speakers, Real Estate Summit, John Colascione
  • 24 Leading Domain Experts Analyze 2017

Popular Stories

New gTLD? Not So Fast; History Suggests New ‘Right of the Dots’ Could = Total Failure

Could Domain Investing Industry End with Legal Provision for Domain “Hoarding”

Does the Domain Industry Suffer From Own Versions of Trumpted “Fake News” Stories?

Websites and Domain Names to Become Insignificant within 20 Years or Less

List of 300+ Cryptocurrency Domain Name Sales and Sale Prices [All Time] (NameBio)

Quotes to Follow

quote icon The domain name is equivalent to Gold. It is the only packaged item which is globally tax-free, portable, with value that is universal across different cultures. quote icon – Frank Schilling

quote icon Domains have and will continue to go up in value faster than any other commodity ever known to man. quote icon – Rick Schwartz

quote icon  Google knows you, your friends, your likes, what entertains you, where you are in the world at any given time. Google will soon predict your next action, your next thought, based on a collaboration of thoughts past. quote icon – John Colascione

Like These Headlines?

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

T.L.D. Brokerage

Domain Brokers

Domain Reseller

Leaving Cash On The Table? Join The Best Domain Reseller Program (discounts + revenue)

Recent SEDO Weekly Sales List Includes “LLL.org” Domain Name Sale for $35,000

PALM BEACH, FL – According to the latest SEDO.com weekly domain sales report, the three letter “LLL” web address "FTP.org" just sold for $35,000.00. Other recent sales of “LLL.org” … [Read More...]

GOOG To Follow FB With Restrictions On Housing, Employment, and Credit Ads

WEST PALM BEACH, FL - Usually Google is a leader in all things advertising, however, a recent update to policy by GOOG (NASDAQ) will have it following Facebook (FB) where the ad giant will implement … [Read More...]

Data Breach: Unauthorized Party Accessed DoorDash Customer Information

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - According to recent reports, a new data security incident has surfaced. DoorDash, a popular food delivery app, detected suspicious activity from the computer network of a … [Read More...]

Domaining blog recommended by Domaining.com
Copyright © 2010-2021 StrategicRevenue.com - Property of Internet Marketing Services Inc.   FeedBurner: RSS   RSS
By using this site you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. If you do not agree, please exit the service.