• Home
  • Domains
  • Internet & Tech
  • Security & Privacy
  • Google & Search
  • Editorial Praise
  • Contact

Strategic Revenue - Domain and Internet News

Internet news authored by John Colascione

Register Domain Names

  • Isn’t Print Dead?
  • Killer Acquisition
  • New gTLD Death
  • Online Censorship
  • Semantic Indexing
  • You’re A Loser
You are here: Home / Domain Names / Pressure on ICANN to Reject Controversial “.ORG” Registry Sale to For-Profit Succeeds

Pressure on ICANN to Reject Controversial “.ORG” Registry Sale to For-Profit Succeeds

May 5, 2020 By John Colascione Leave a Comment

*** Here Is A List Of Some Of The Best Domain Name Resources Available ***

Register Domain Names

LOS ANGELES, CA – On Thursday, April 30, ICANN, The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, based in Los Angeles, CA, made a tough decision to protect the global non-profit community, by rejecting a controversial deal announced in November 2019, that PIR, Public Interest Registry, a non-profit company which owns and manages the rights to the registry for ‘.org’ domain names, would be sold and ultimately converted to a for-profit entity owned by Ethos Capital. Equally threatening, the deal was announced just months after the “.org” registry agreement, held by PIR, was renewed with approval for long standing price-caps, removed.

The world’s non-profit organizations, many of which have long-used their online addresses to relay their missions’ non-profit status, remain safe from being milked for increased registration fees by for-profit directors and investors. Photo credit Shutterstock licensed.

The idea, right from the start, that ICANN would approve such a transfer shocked the entire domain name community, while also capturing the hearts and minds of those far outside the industry, with article after article and letter after letter to the ICANN Board urging it to reject the deal.

RELATED: WYDEN: “I WILL EXPLORE EVERY AVENUE TO ENSURE USERS, NONPROFITS ARE PROTECTED”

While the Internet’s ordinary watchdogs took sharp notice and voiced those concerns, the tumultuous situation also attracted the attention of at least six congress persons and attorney generals, one of which was the attorney general of California, Xavier Becerra, who was particularly threatening to the entire situation as he governs the state in which ICANN operates.

The Office of the Attorney General has the duty to supervise charitable organizations under California Corporations Code section 5250, and Government Code sections 12580 through 12599.8. The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), as a registered nonprofit in California, is subject to regulation by the California Attorney General. It is my understanding that ICANN is in the process of reviewing for approval the proposed transfer of Public Interest Registry (PIR), a Pennsylvania nonprofit corporation, to Ethos Capital, a for-profit corporation.

Becerra played such a critical role in the deal, that out of the multitude of congressional letters and statements signed off by representatives such as Ronald Wyden, Richard Blumenthal, then presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren, and Anna Eshoo – it was Becerra who was specifically mentioned in the announcement.

Throughout this process, the ICANN Board has worked thoughtfully and thoroughly to determine if it is reasonable under PIR’s Registry Agreements for ICANN to either approve or withhold consent to the proposed change of control. Before making our determination, the Board, among other things:

Approved Board Resolutions | Special Meeting of the ICANN Board
  • Conducted thorough due diligence
  • Received and reviewed hundreds of pages of documentation and responses provided by PIR, ISOC and Ethos Capital following ICANN issuing three requests for more information
  • Was briefed extensively by ICANN org
  • Received and considered more than 30 letters from stakeholders
  • Considered input from an ICANN67 public forum, views of the community and others who weighed in after we received PIR’s Public Interest Commitments
  • Considered the opinions expressed in the California Attorney General’s Office letter sent to ICANN on 15 April 2020

That letter, on the 15th of April, was actually the second letter sent from Xavier Becerra, with the first on January 23, 2020.

ICANN, which has stricken a negative cord with many industry watchdogs due to its worsening habit of ignoring public comments on controversial issues, despite there severity, had a new type of problem; comments near impossible to ignore.

RELATED: ICANN, PIR, ETHOS CAPITAL “CIRCUS” CONTINUES WITH YET ANOTHER LETTER FROM CALIFORNIA AG

Despite a comment by Andrew Sullivan, the president and CEO of the Internet Society (ISOC), which owns Public Interest Registry, who in Nov 2019 told The Register:

Most people don’t care about the .org sell-off – and nothing short of a court order will stop it”

Andrew Sullivan, President and CEO of Internet Society.

The deal is now dead in the water and this development is not only good for the global community, and all non-profits, but it is also good for the future and value of the .org domain – by itself. It reiterates a viable and important statement when in use and allows the .org domain to maintain that it is indisputably unique, validates its credibility in the name space, while ensuring its affordability.

What say you? Would this deal have gone through if not pressured by strong opposition by Attorney General of California, Xavier Becerra?

John Colascione
John Colascione

About The Author: John Colascione is Chief Executive Officer of Internet Marketing Services Inc. He specializes in Website Monetization, is a Google AdWords Certified Professional, authored a ‘how to’ book called ”Mastering Your Website‘, and is a key player in several Internet related businesses through his search engine strategy brand Searchen Networks®

Filed Under: Domain Names Tagged With: .org, Anna Eshoo, Attorney General, Attorney Generals, California, Comments, Congress, Controversial, Elizabeth Warren, Ethos Capital, ICANN, Letter, Non-profit, Non-profits, Organization, Organizations, PIR, Price Caps, Public Comments, Public Interest Registry, Registry, Registry Agreement, Registry Agreements, Registry Operator, Registry Operator Agreements, Registry Service, Registry Services, Reject, Richard Blumenthal, Ron Wyden, Ronald Wyden, Stakeholders, Watchdogs, Wyden, Xavier Becerra

*** Here Is A List Of Some Of The Best Domain Name Resources Available ***

Register Domain Names

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search This Site

by: John Colascione

John Colascione

Logo
John Colascione is Chief Executive of Internet Marketing Services Inc. He specializes in Website Monetization, authored a book called Mastering Your Website, and is a key player in several Internet businesses through his brand SEARCHEN®

The Published Reporter

The Published Reporter

Fellow Me

Twitter

In The News

  • DNJournal: New Book From Veteran Domainer
  • From Brandable to Exact-Match Geo Domain
  • InnovateLI: Two Deals, One Very Interesting Digital
  • Internet Commerce Association: John Colascione
  • NamesCon: Featured Attendee: John Colascione
  • Long Island Media Inc, SmartCEO, Future 50
  • Speakers, Name Summit, John Colascione
  • Speakers, Real Estate Summit, John Colascione
  • 24 Leading Domain Experts Analyze 2017

Popular Stories

New gTLD? Not So Fast; History Suggests New ‘Right of the Dots’ Could = Total Failure

Could Domain Investing Industry End with Legal Provision for Domain “Hoarding”

Does the Domain Industry Suffer From Own Versions of Trumpted “Fake News” Stories?

Websites and Domain Names to Become Insignificant within 20 Years or Less

List of 300+ Cryptocurrency Domain Name Sales and Sale Prices [All Time] (NameBio)

Quotes to Follow

quote icon The domain name is equivalent to Gold. It is the only packaged item which is globally tax-free, portable, with value that is universal across different cultures. quote icon – Frank Schilling

quote icon Domains have and will continue to go up in value faster than any other commodity ever known to man. quote icon – Rick Schwartz

quote icon  Google knows you, your friends, your likes, what entertains you, where you are in the world at any given time. Google will soon predict your next action, your next thought, based on a collaboration of thoughts past. quote icon – John Colascione

Like These Headlines?

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

T.L.D. Brokerage

Domain Brokers

Domain Reseller

Leaving Cash On The Table? Join The Best Domain Reseller Program (discounts + revenue)

Recent SEDO Weekly Sales List Includes “LLL.org” Domain Name Sale for $35,000

PALM BEACH, FL – According to the latest SEDO.com weekly domain sales report, the three letter “LLL” web address "FTP.org" just sold for $35,000.00. Other recent sales of “LLL.org” … [Read More...]

GOOG To Follow FB With Restrictions On Housing, Employment, and Credit Ads

WEST PALM BEACH, FL - Usually Google is a leader in all things advertising, however, a recent update to policy by GOOG (NASDAQ) will have it following Facebook (FB) where the ad giant will implement … [Read More...]

Data Breach: Unauthorized Party Accessed DoorDash Customer Information

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - According to recent reports, a new data security incident has surfaced. DoorDash, a popular food delivery app, detected suspicious activity from the computer network of a … [Read More...]

Domaining blog recommended by Domaining.com
Copyright © 2010-2021 StrategicRevenue.com - Property of Internet Marketing Services Inc.   FeedBurner: RSS   RSS
By using this site you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. If you do not agree, please exit the service.